The Responsibility of Rank.

When I began my journey in Karate nearly 60 years ago, the path to belt promotions was a slow and deliberate one. A year between promotions was the norm, and the concept of multiple levels within the black belt was foreign to me. It wasn’t until later that I learned about Tsuruoka Masami Sensei, who held a Godan rank—a significant milestone that represented the pinnacle of achievement in martial arts. Fast forward to today, and the landscape has transformed dramatically. An overwhelming number of individuals, both skillful and unskillful, now hold high ranks. The traditional model of teacher promotion, once the only valid path to advancement, has largely been supplanted by ‘mutual advancement’ groups, where ranks are often exchanged with little regard for the depth of skill or understanding. This shift raises important questions about the true nature of rank and the responsibilities that accompany it.

So let’s look at the origins.

To understand the origins of the modern ranking system, which spans from First to Tenth Dan, we must turn our attention to Kano Jigoro, the visionary founder of modern Judo. This system is just one of his significant contributions to martial arts and education. Kano Sensei was not only a pioneering martial artist but also an accomplished educator and politician. His influential roles included serving as the Director of Primary Education from 1898 to 1901 and later as the President of the Tokyo Higher Normal School from 1901 to 1920.

In the early twentieth century, Kano took a groundbreaking approach by advocating for the inclusion of judo and kendo in the Japanese public school curriculum, thereby recognizing the value of martial arts in personal development and education. In 1912, he founded the Japan Amateur Athletic Association (Dai Nippon Taiiku Kyokai), which was responsible for overseeing amateur sports throughout Japan. That same year, he represented Japan as an official delegate and member of the Olympic Advisory Committee at the Stockholm Olympics, where he played a key role in organizing the Far Asia All Athletic Championships.

Kano Sensei’s relationship with Gichin Funakoshi, the founder of Shotokan Karate, further exemplifies his commitment to the martial arts community. A close friend and supporter of Funakoshi, Kano held a deep respect for Okinawan Karate and shared his colleague’s dedication to making budo accessible to all. Throughout his life, he championed the idea that martial arts should be open to everyone, regardless of gender, age, race, or religious beliefs, laying the groundwork for the inclusivity that characterizes modern martial arts today.

So what happened?

The transformation of the once-coveted achievement of rank into something more ordinary and pedestrian raises important questions about the evolution of martial arts culture. Over the decades, the rigorous standards that once defined rank promotions have often been diluted. In the early days, earning a new belt was a mark of significant dedication, skill, and understanding of the art. It required years of disciplined training, personal growth, and a deep connection to the philosophy behind martial arts.

However, as the popularity of martial arts surged globally, particularly in the latter half of the twentieth century, the demand for accessible training and quick progression became more pronounced. This shift led to the rise of various schools and organizations that adopted more lenient promotion criteria, often prioritizing quantity over quality. The introduction of “mutual advancement” groups allowed practitioners to promote one another, eroding the traditional hierarchies that helped maintain the integrity of rank.

Additionally, the commercialization of martial arts contributed to this trend. With the advent of martial arts as a mainstream sport and fitness activity, the emphasis shifted towards attracting new students and retaining them through rapid belt promotions. This focus on enrollment and retention sometimes overshadowed the foundational principles of discipline and mastery that rank was originally meant to signify.

As a result, the value and meaning of rank have been diminished in many circles. What was once a reflection of hard-earned expertise and commitment has, in some cases, become a mere symbol, often awarded for participation rather than true accomplishment. This evolution invites reflection on how practitioners and instructors can reclaim the significance of rank, fostering an environment where the journey of mastery is honored and respected once more.

So how do we restore the respect and value to true Karatedo rank?

This revival begins with setting higher expectations for rank holders and ensuring that individuals are truly worthy of their titles. It’s not just about possessing physical skills; the right mental aptitude and character must also be paramount in assessing a practitioner’s readiness for advancement.

The Zen saying, “Before enlightenment, chop wood, carry water. After enlightenment, chop wood, carry water,” encapsulates this philosophy beautifully. It reminds us that the essence of martial arts lies not in the attainment of rank itself, but in the continuous practice and embodiment of its principles. A truly senior rank holder understands that their journey is ongoing and that humility and diligence are essential.

You can identify these genuine leaders within the dojo or a broader community at large; they are the ones who speak softly, promoting ideals rather than their own self-interest. They serve as examples for all Budoka, demonstrating that true mastery transcends mere technical ability. Their actions reflect a deep understanding of the art’s philosophy, and they inspire those around them to strive for personal growth and integrity.

By fostering an environment that prioritizes character development alongside skill acquisition, we can cultivate a culture that honors the true spirit of Karatedo. This approach not only enhances the value of rank but also ensures that those who hold it are worthy representatives of the martial arts community, committed to the principles of respect, humility, and lifelong learning.

Ganbarimasho ~ C.Borkowski